Doing stand up is fucking hard. Hating on Brendan because he didnt kill it during a show is harsh. I'm not even really defending him in the sense where I think he is genuinely funny, but it's not easy finding yourself as a comedian, especially when you are already known for doing something else.
For some reason it seems like people want tenure, they want their funny man to be a lifer in the game, you gotta have stripes to resonate.
5 years doing stand up is not long at all. Some guys take over a decade to start hitting. Even Rogan isn't really that funny. Honestly. His stand up is crude and very conversational. I dont feel like he is putting on a show, it's more like a silly back and forth about current events or trendy topics.
There are only a few REALLY good stand up comedians in the game at any given time. Burr is a great example of a top class performer as and funny man. He is intrinsically humorous but also is so experienced and talented as a professional comedian, it really hits home with almost everyone. No one bad talks Burr.
Eddie Murphy was cut from that same cloth, Chris Rock, Kat William's these guys are just funny without trying to be.
Schaub is trying very hard, when he gets more comfortable and becomes more naturally funny I think he will be fine. He has a great work ethic, cant deny that. Most guys would never even try doing stand up.
Theo Von is one of those outliers where he is funny as fuck without trying to be, but also has this very unique style where he is obviously not taking himself too seriously by telling fantastical stories etc. There are many ways to be comical, and he has found his way doing something not many people are doing. So Schaub can do the same if he keeps developing sets.
RIP Billy Conforto.