MTG thread
- Thread starter brekk
- Start date
zzeris
King Turd of Shit Hill
- 18,926
- 73,882
That's my problem with it. There's not a lot of food generation outside of Oko and that one 3/3. That leaves Goose as an extremely effective Turn 2 ramp, especially for multi-colored+ decks, a minor mana sink....and a key part of an Oko deck. That's pretty fucking weak so far. We have plenty of ramp so I don't care, but it's not a very strong card.
Sterling
El Presidente
- 12,984
- 7,890
yeah if you're not playing 2 or 3 different cards that make food, that would make it pretty sketchy. 1 shot of ramp then 2 mana to make 1 mana later seems kind of weak. but if you have 10-12 cards in your deck that make food then you can get 2 or 3 mana out of it before you run out.
- 1
You guys are over analyzing it.
Goose only needs to tap once to get value.
With check lands and llanowar elf rotating a one shot BOP is very much standard playable.
3 Color green will want it, also ToE is also shaping up to be an equipment set to heaven forbid we get a constructed playable equipment that can go on a 0/2 flyer.
Right now this is the only way to get the multiple 3 drop planeswalkers out turn 2 with out relying on the randomness of the sloth+land.
It also randomly daggers burn, everyone knows you bolt the bird on turn 1 but this one punishes you for doing so by leaving 3 points if life gain on the table.
1. The card is good
2. It will see play in meta decks.
3. Stop thinking about food.dec that's draft shit you just need one food.
Goose only needs to tap once to get value.
With check lands and llanowar elf rotating a one shot BOP is very much standard playable.
3 Color green will want it, also ToE is also shaping up to be an equipment set to heaven forbid we get a constructed playable equipment that can go on a 0/2 flyer.
Right now this is the only way to get the multiple 3 drop planeswalkers out turn 2 with out relying on the randomness of the sloth+land.
It also randomly daggers burn, everyone knows you bolt the bird on turn 1 but this one punishes you for doing so by leaving 3 points if life gain on the table.
1. The card is good
2. It will see play in meta decks.
3. Stop thinking about food.dec that's draft shit you just need one food.
- 3
zzeris
King Turd of Shit Hill
- 18,926
- 73,882
What are your thoughts on Oko while we are discussing food? Obviously not as strong as Teferi but? What about the other 3 cost PW?
Oko is good but I think he's going to be more powerful in older formats.
The +1 to remove shit like urza, goyf, engineer, challace of the void, ensnaring bridge thopter foundry batterskull etc etc etc etc is very powerful.
Sure they get a 3/3 but that will be smaller than your goyf or icefang coatl and won't instantly kill you like urza or engineer will.
- 1
pharmakos
soʞɐɯɹɐɥd
- 16,306
- -2,236
Might be abusable in current standard with all the recent +1/+1 counter synergy? Maybe even something ridiculous like Simic Ascendency?
Four color Gates of the dead with this, Yarok, Simic Ascendency, and Evolution Sage? Hahahaha either jankiest of jank or the next Kethis combo. Obviously one is more likely but hey you don't come up with decks like Kethis by looking at the obvious stuff.
Last edited:
I see this card as a sideboard card in Modern for sure.
I still believe that the actual card "Counter Spell" would not be played that much in Modern it's too slow. A harder to cast and more limited counter spell won't do any better.
BUT....
Turn 1: Thoughtseize
Turn 2+ This card seems like a house
Most things in Modern cost 2 and the ability to use it as a counter spell or a kill spell is powerful.
ONLY if you are on the play this card is probably too slow on the draw.
So 2 in the board for when you know you are on the play. Keep your Fatal Pushes/Spell Snare/Pierces in the main.
- 1
pharmakos
soʞɐɯɹɐɥd
- 16,306
- -2,236
Even with fetches in the format you don't think it's main able? I don't really know Modern very well so I'm just guessing here tho. Lots of Spikes talk about this card being potentially OP.
Fatal push deals with everything this does for 1 black Mana.
Two Mana counterspells are too slow when you are on the draw and can't counter the goyf or or stoneforge and late game you would want to be casting cryptic command.
There's a reason the most played counterspell in the format is free and the second most played counterspell costs 4 Mana.
You either have to do a ton of shit (Cryptic Command) or do it as early as possible (force of negation)
A two Mana kill spell better suck your dick when in the same format as Fatal Push, Lightning bolt and path to exile.
I think that's a good card.
Wrath plus threat is ways standard playable.
Edit: you can wrath, play him a few turns later and bounce him to your hand to wrath again with 3feri.
- 2
- 1
pharmakos
soʞɐɯɹɐɥd
- 16,306
- -2,236
And now you are starting to see the sort of thing I was seeing when I was think this Adventure Control deck might not be so crazy after all haha. One of the Adventure cards has a Gravedigger effect, that and Teferi and etc etc, that's infinite recursion on all your 2-for-1 cards (of which everything in the deck could be!)