This is a pretty retarded conversation. Brady is up there but would I take him with another team in some of those situations? Not so sure. I remember Pey Pey dominating with his arm and intellect and am pretty sure he could do it anywhere. Is Rodgers superior arm going to outdo Mannings knowledge of the game? Are we remembering good Manning or that slack-armed detriment of the past few years? Based on actual history Brady will be the best QB of all time because rings do count. Just like the Dallas OL should be the MVP this year but they won't be.