The Strain

Div

Silver Knight of the Realm
322
61
I wasn't blown away by the pilot but it wasn't horrible.

I'll prolly just wait until the season is over and blitz through it.
 

khorum

Murder Apologist
24,338
81,363
Pilots for closely scripted serial shows rarely hook you in nowadays. These aren't episodic self-contained shows, the pilot has to fit into a broader season-wide 3-act structure. It's actually pretty promising that the pilot was as engaging as it was considering that most serial cable dramas are written to take 3/4 episodes to establish itself. But then, I never read the book.

That said, I actually kinda liked that Pete Russo was being cuckolded by a wine-sipping Sears hipster. If we have to put up with an obnoxious Skyleresque milf at least we'll have a solid reason to hate her.
 

Cantatus

Lord Nagafen Raider
1,437
79
I think one of the biggest sins with these types of shows is the professional scientist who should otherwise be intelligent doing ridiculously stupid things just to further the plot (see: Helix). I don't think The Strain was necessarily guilty of this (save the medical examiner deciding to pick up the beating heart), but I don't think they did a great job working around it either. It's like the writers are aware of this trope and want to avoid it, so they just throw in a couple lines of dialogue to justify what's happening. It has this forced sort of nonchalance that made some of the scenes and the characters feel really artificial and contrived.

Take them opening the coffin (I called it a coffin!): This would normally be a scene where you're asking how the scientist could be so reckless to do something like that, but we get Samwise throwing in a line about how they did a bunch of scans and nothing showed up. It really doesn't change that they're doing something stupid (they've never seen a virus like this before and assume their tests will detect it?), but just hand-waves it away. And then their reactions to seeing it full of dirt had this unexpected air of indifference. Looking at the security footage was similar to this: They act like seeing the coffin lifted off the ground in a fraction of a second is something that happens everyday, and then immediately jump to exclaiming that that massive coffin that was moved several feet in that short timemuststill be in the airport, because why wouldn't it be?

Perhaps I'm nitpicking and over-analyzing here, but it almost pushes things in the other direction where their actions become even less realistic. Rather than them acting stupid and accepting that these are stupid people, we get the reminder that these are professionals who know what they're doing - which makes it even more glaring when they step outside of that and act ridiculous or have such subdued reactions to what's going on around them. At this point, the people feel fake. It's not enough to put me off the show since I know most shows have a rocky first episode, but the writing and directing were sloppy in a way that doesn't leave me optimistic.
 

Slaythe

<Bronze Donator>
3,389
141
The part similar to that which bothered me was when he discovers the worm, knows immediately it's the carrier and then like sits there playing with it. Oh man, look at it playfully nibbling at me. Thankfully, while it can pierce through skin with no issue and causes unexplained instant death, it won't get through these latex gloves. So cute.

It's the biggest complaint with all TV though (people acting so stupid it isn't believable), but it seems to be most common in anything remotely resembling horror (obviously TWD is the worst about this). Like show runners want to continue to jam tropes that have existed since the 60s down our throats. I await some large scale TV show renaissance where all TV writers realize why a show like The Wire so so critically acclaimed and then as a result put in that little extra effort to not make things so dumb. We see this every once in a while with a show like Breaking Bad, obviously, but I look forward to the day when every show on a station like FX lives up to the quality of say, The Shield.
 

Bondurant

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
3,837
4,786
Peter Russo definitely does better acting bald than with glue hair ! On a more serious note, I didn't like most scenes, probably because it's a pilot and some scenes probably got axed, which makes them kind of cheesy. Like going full federal quarantine on some plane but unloading a mysterious 7ft tall wood coffin is okay enough ? Also that badass vampire couldn't just wait for CDC people and infect them in the plane ? I don't know, most of the scenes look silly. Maybe they'll get their stuff straight on the next episodes.
 

elidib

Vyemm Raider
2,061
3,486
Second episode was much the same as the first episode I guess.... I really had to fast forward through the AA meeting part, that was the most awkward, boring, and badly acted section of TV I've watched in I don't know how long.
 

TJT

Mr. Poopybutthole
<Gold Donor>
41,059
103,127
Peter Russo definitely does better acting bald than with glue hair ! On a more serious note, I didn't like most scenes, probably because it's a pilot and some scenes probably got axed, which makes them kind of cheesy. Like going full federal quarantine on some plane but unloading a mysterious 7ft tall wood coffin is okay enough ? Also that badass vampire couldn't just wait for CDC people and infect them in the plane ? I don't know, most of the scenes look silly. Maybe they'll get their stuff straight on the next episodes.
The books, as boring as they were, made a great deal of effort to focus on the biological vectors of their style of vampirism. So if he had bit the CDC guys on the plane, if they didn't scream they would just collapse and the CDC would probably quarantined in reaction. Just leave it to be one of the vehicles of the show. But on that same note, it took how long and the morgue bodies waltzing out of the place didn't tip a bell?
 

Frenzied Wombat

Potato del Grande
14,730
31,802
For such a great premise and producer, how did they manage to collect such a useless ensemble of actors? Some of the "emotional" scenes are so poorly acted I find myself guffawing/chortling constantly.
 

Chanur

Shit Posting Professional
<Gold Donor>
26,744
39,092
I am enjoying the show despite some hand waving that is common in every single show and horror movie ever made.
 

Homsar

Silver Baronet of the Realm
8,742
7,520
Agree, hopefully they can squeeze in another therapy session before hand
 

Fight

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
4,584
5,408
turrible.png
 

Oatlord_sl

shitlord
202
2
The script was questionable this last episode. "I can't take ten minutes to see my son right now, busy fightin virus. But I can block out a few hours to go cry at an AA meeting."

But hey, nosferatu and Kevin Durand. Gotta watch.
 

Void

Experiencer
<Gold Donor>
9,458
11,146
I had sort of blocked it out, but the rat catcher guy was far and away the best part of the first book. Glad they got someone big and imposing to play him.
 

Slaythe

<Bronze Donator>
3,389
141
I had sort of blocked it out, but the rat catcher guy was far and away the best part of the first book. Glad they got someone big and imposing to play him.
I feel like Tom Savini should play this guy. Maybe it was just Lost commando dude's handle bars that made me think that though.