Whiskey

  • Guest, a new site style is ready for use. The poll to change the "default" style, and provide your feedback can be found here

Araxen

<Donors Crew>
Jul 30, 2016
6,015
15h 30m
1,527
#1
I'm looking for a decent $20 bottle of whiskey for the weekend. I normally drink Templeton Rye which is $40 but money is tight right now and I need something a little bit cheaper to drink.


I'll take suggestions too for more expensive whiskey when money frees up a little.
 

Rime

Knight of the Realm
Jul 30, 2016
1,654
16h 21m
447
#2
Tullamore Dew is what I drink, during those rare events that I have to have a drink. Though that is because it was the drink of my Grandfather.

Around $25 for a 750ml bottle.

If you like it, you can try the 12 Year Special ($35ish) or the 10 Year Single ($40+). I have not had the 12 Year, but I have enjoyed a few glasses of the 10 year when visiting my Grandfather.
 

Urgoslav

Treasured Member
Jul 30, 2016
468
3h 28m
472
#3
Been drinking Forty Creek: Barrel Select, fairly cheap Canadian whiskey but I've enjoyed it. $20-$25

 

Ishad

Lord Nagafen Raider
Jul 30, 2016
2,235
22h 26m
335
#5
$20 dollar bottle recommendations:
Rittenhouse 100
1792 ridgemont reserve
Eagle rare

$30 dollar bottles:
Elmer t lee
Rowans creek

$40+ bottles:
Noah's mill
Willett family reserve rye
Blantons
 

Falstaff

Trakanon Raider
Jul 30, 2016
5,774
8h 7m
533
#6
Check out the liquor thread at the bottom of this page. It has some good suggestions.
 

lurkingdirk

<Donors Crew>
Jul 22, 2016
12,792
1d 10m
2,732
#7
Try Canadian Club rye whiskey. It's a lot of bang for the buck.
Even more bang for the buck is Canadian Mist. About 17$ for 1.75 litres. Neither are awesome whiskey, and both are rye based, but they're better than a kick in the head with a frozen boot.
 
Jul 30, 2016
95
5h 3m
13
#8
Rebel Yell is good standard affordable whiskey. Costs $20.99 for a handle at my local liquor store. That's my maintstay drinkin' whiskey.
 

Khane

Doesn't know about marriage
Jul 30, 2016
12,165
1d 22h 30m
2,503
#9
Rebel Yell is good standard affordable whiskey. Costs $20.99 for a handle at my local liquor store. That's my maintstay drinkin' whiskey.
Seconded. Actually a very drinkable bourbon and as good or better than many 40-50 dollar bottles.

If you find yourself with some extra disposable income at some point in the future and you like Rye whiskies I'd recommend Whistle Pig. It'll run you about $80 for a bottle but goddamn is it good.
 

Tea_sl

shitlord
Jul 30, 2016
1,019
0
0
#10
It's fucking crazy to me that you guys are recommending Canadian club and rebel yell*. Drink what you like, but Jesus.

Recommendations from what I like best to almost as much in the $20 - $25 range:

1792
Elmer T. Lee
Rittenhouse 100
Sazerac Rye
W. L. Weller

I could keep going, but pick one of those.

*rebel yell isn't horrible, but there's much, much better out there. I also can't think of a $40+ bourbon that it would hold a candle to, and I've had nearly all of them.
 

grumblethorn

<Donor All-Stars>
Jul 30, 2016
2,963
12h 10m
1,418
#12
Nothing beats Early Times for price and hilarity of coming in a plastic bottle.
 

Drinsic

privileged shitlord
<Donors Crew>
Jul 30, 2016
3,308
12h 15m
762
#13
Early Times is fucking awful, Rebel Yell was my go-to dirt cheap whiskey in college.
 

Chanur

Not Soygen
<Donor All-Stars>
Jul 22, 2016
14,007
1d 17h 50m
4,561
#14
I didn't get to try the Templeton when I was in Iowa, is it good?
 

BrutulTM

Good, bad, I'm the guy with the gun.
<Donors Crew>
Jul 31, 2016
7,874
15h 53m
2,447
#15
This stuff is pretty cheap. I don't know if I'd call it great, but it does have the distinction of being mentioned in a couple episodes of Mad Men and it was supposedly drunk by Charles Bukowski. It has high rye content similar to Bulleit so it would be considered a "full bodied" bourbon. If you're used to Crown Royal this stuff will kick your ass.



My old Granddad always used to have a bottle of this under the kitchen sink. I never saw him take a drink in my life, but he must have snuck one now and then. I mostly thought it was funny because the only person I knew that drank it matched the name on the bottle.
 

Tea_sl

shitlord
Jul 30, 2016
1,019
0
0
#16
My granddad also drank the Old Grand Dad. It's not the worst thing ever, but it's hardly good either. Sometimes I buy a handle.

If you gonna drink swill whiskey in the $10 price range, may I recommend you go with scotch. Cheap scotch at least has a pleasant peat smoke flavor to go along with the uhh... generous cuts of swill whiskey.
 

lurkingdirk

<Donors Crew>
Jul 22, 2016
12,792
1d 10m
2,732
#19
Cheap scotch is like drinking liquid gravel
This is crap. Sorry, I don't mean disrespect. But no one, not even the very rich, are opening the finest Scotch every time they pour a drink. Try a bunch of cheaper stuff, find what you enjoy, have that on hand. Hence this thread - ask for suggestions. Good idea.

I have very good, very expensive stuff. I don't drink it every time I pour something to sip on.
 

Joeboo

Trakanon Raider
Jul 30, 2016
8,153
0
122
#20
Well to be fair im not a big fan of scotch anyways, so I've had some cheap ones that seemed overly harsh, even good ones are a little rough compared to what i usually drink(whiskey/bourbon)