2021 NFL Offseason: QB Carousel Imminent -- Retirement Boogaloo

Every other stats than SB appearances, cousins and tannehill easily outdo him. It's not even close.

And lets not forget in that playoff run, in three games he threw for 427 yards, 2 tds, 3 ints. Trent dilfer did better.

Kirun said:

Yeah, a list that has Prescott at fucking 7 makes total sense... .

Jimmy G is practically the same fucking QB as Cousins and Tannehill, except he has actually been to a SB. There's no way he's worse than that.

Click to expand...

Keep hating. Cowboys have another decade of top 10 QB talent incoming.

Nester said:

This is the list, for those curious.

You need to remove Brees and Rivers,

QB Index: Ranking the 59 starting quarterbacks of the 2020 NFL season

NFL.com editors evaluated every quarterback who started a game (including the playoffs) during the 2020 NFL season to create a complete ranking from 1 to 59. Did winning Super Bowl LV give Tom Brady enough juice to knock MVP Aaron Rodgers from the top spo

www.nfl.com

Click to expand...

Smith ranked above Bridgewater and Trubinksy is interesting.

Merrith said:

Smith ranked above Bridgewater and Trubinksy is interesting.

Click to expand...

If Josh Allen pulls an Andrew Luck Tomorrow, I am picking Smith out of those 3 for who i want to be a our new QB*

*Subject to a very detailed medical report.

Nester said:

If Josh Allen pulls an Andrew Luck Tomorrow, I am picking Smith out of those 3 for who i want to be a our new QB*

*Subject to a very detailed medical report.

Click to expand...

Being 100% honest, I think you're crazy if you do so. Completely immobile, and forget pushing the ball downfield like Allen does. Singletary and Moss would end up catching 80 balls, though.

Ameraves said:

I can't think of a single other NFC West player outside of the 49ers that I really like and want to see win, besides Fitz. Dude just works hard and seems like an all around good guy. I hope he gives it one more go, but I don't see the Cardinals having a real shot at the SB anyway.

Click to expand...

I agree with this as if you change Niners to the Seahawks as well. Dude is a beast and a class individual.

BrutulTM said:

That wasn't because Jimmy played badly, it was because the Vikings and Packers defenses were totally helpless against the running game. They had no reason to pass in those games because they were getting 8 yards per carry. You could definitely make the argument that it was the defense that blew the game in the superbowl. They were up by 10 in the 3rd quarter before the Chiefs made 3 touchdowns in 7 minutes. Jimmy did have a chance to win the game with a pass to Sanders that he totally missed, but the D definitely blew it at the end.

Click to expand...

Yeah, it was the defense and run game that won those first two games, without a doubt. But it's not like he was excelling in the opportunities he did have in those two games. When it came time for Jimmy to step up in the SB, he didn't. You can't rely on your run game to win every game or to get third and 5+. The 49ers had 140+ rushing yards in the SB, which is still a good number.

The only reason the Chiefs got those touchdowns so fast was because the offense failed to stay on the field at all. Blame the defense, sure, but the offense didn't give them a break either.

I'm definitely in the Jimmy G is in the 15-20 range as a QB tops. This board trashes Cousins to no end, but Jimmy has just as many turnovers for the time he's played (his career int % is higher than Cousins). His lone complete season Jimmy had 23 potential turnovers (ints plus fumbles) -- and that was with him not being the focus of the offense. I think you can easily make the case that every full season from Cousins was better than that 2019 season of Jimmy's.

Merrith said:

Being 100% honest, I think you're crazy if you do so. Completely immobile, and forget pushing the ball downfield like Allen does. Singletary and Moss would end up catching 80 balls, though.

Click to expand...

You gave me 3 crummy options!

I took the kick in the balls over a thumb in the eye.


I like Teddy, but he is made of glass. MORE So then Alex imo.
Mitch wont be in the NFL in 2022

Nester said:

You gave me 3 crummy options!

I took the kick in the balls over a thumb in the eye.


I like Teddy, but he is made of glass. MORE So then Alex imo.
Mitch wont be in the NFL in 2022

Click to expand...

Alex before his injury was for sure better than either of them. His mobility was an underrated aspect of his game and it definitely takes a lot away now that he can't move as well.

DickTrickle said:

Alex before his injury was for sure better than either of them. His mobility was an underrated aspect of his game and it definitely takes a lot away now that he can't move as well.

Click to expand...

I don't think he was even that good for us prior to getting hurt in 2018, although he was obviously better due to still having his mobility. I do feel for the guy if that is just gone and not coming back as a result of it all, because it really hurts his ability to keep playing (if that is what he wants to do).

Nester said:

You gave me 3 crummy options!

I took the kick in the balls over a thumb in the eye.


I like Teddy, but he is made of glass. MORE So then Alex imo.
Mitch wont be in the NFL in 2022

Click to expand...

Mitch will sign somewhere. It'll be a little crazy if he isn't at least a backup somewhere.

The most infuriating thing for me when Smith was a Chief is all the horrible sacks he would take. He didn't even have a ton in those last few years but so many would come at the worst times.

Wat?

Its hard to be down on your team when you have one of the best QB's in the league. But the Seahawks doing jack shit so far in free agency while all the other teams in the division improve a lot only further helps push Russ out the door. And I usually take free agency moves with a grain of salt. But the Seahawks have so many holes to fill and no draft picks.

Animosity said:

Its hard to be down on your team when you have one of the best QB's in the league. But the Seahawks doing jack shit so far in free agency while all the other teams in the division improve a lot only further helps push Russ out the door. And I usually take free agency moves with a grain of salt. But the Seahawks have so many holes to fill and no draft picks.

Click to expand...

Carroll's next o-line project will totally hit! Wasn't there some dude who had never played OL before that he tried to turn in to one a few years back?

DickTrickle said:

Carroll's next o-line project will totally hit! Wasn't there some dude who had never played OL before that he tried to turn in to one a few years back?

Click to expand...

Hes done that multiple times now. I think Sweezy was the only one that turned a career out of it. Waiting all summer and sign scraps for your starting line hasnt worked for 10 years now. Ridiculous Pete is getting another shot at rebuilding this.