If your beef is with the visuals, youre entitled to your opinion.
I hate the graphics but I could live with them if the game was good. I put up with WoW for a month after all. My beef with this game is that it's just another disposable summer blockbuster. That's what all gaming companies do now, I get it, I don't really blame SOE.
But they are fucking scumbags for talking it up and starting the presentation with how people have formed serious relationships in EQ and got married, had kids, all that stuff. They say all that and then they present "Guild Wars Craft 3", designed 100% with the intention of sucking in a few million kids and getting them to blow their pocket money on orzum swordz before they realize it's 'ghey' and look for the next game to hop to.
How you could not be excited with the possibilities that the voxel engine brings?
I was playing with voxels in the 90s with commanche and shit. I've heard the hype a million times before. This really does take it to the next level, the engine is amazing, the technology is amazing, is is going to provide a whole new angle and direction for the future of MMO's.
I just think it's one that will be lapped up by easily manipulated, simple minded tools. Anyone else will not fall for this shit.
Now, does the combat look somewhat suspect? Yes. However, we have seen very little. I'm hoping for less flash and more strategy and I have a feeling you agree with me on that. We have to wait and see. I am done with ta targeting but dont want a button mash fest either.
Is there a word for getting deja vu of a previous deja vu of a previous deja vu? Because that's what I'm getting now. EQ2 was the big hope, then Vanguard, then Age of Conan, then Warhammer, then Rift, and GW2, blah blah blah. They are all full of shit. They don't care about me one bit, I am part of an audience of maybe 1 million people if we're lucky, maybe half of that. They only care about the audience of 14 something million people who played WoW. Even if you only manage to attract half of them to play your game, if that 7 million people play it for a month or two and each buy a kool badazzz mount and sword, then you double trippled or whatever multipled your money spent making the game. That's all SOE cares about now.
McMMO's are here to stay.
I think you need to wait for further info on the meta-game. How will storybricks play out. How do the dungeons/raids play out.
Basicly Kruegen's point: you've shown the sandbox, need to see more of the game.
But I saw no sandbox. I saw Guild Wars 3.